He said she said fault car accidents in Texas

He said she said fault car accidents in Texas

As a driver, you always do your best to follow the rules of the road and operate your vehicle safely. However, even the most cautious drivers can end up in an auto accident due to the negligence or reckless behavior of another motorist. When a collision occurs, determining who is at fault is critical, especially if injuries are involved. In some cases, the at-fault driver will accept responsibility for causing the crash. But in other situations, each driver blames the other - leading to a "he said, she said" dispute over the events that led to the accident. Talk with a Texas Car Accident Lawyer to get started if you feel you have a case. 

Determining Fault in a He Said, She Said Car Accident

Determining fault in a “he said, she said” car accident can be complicated without independent witnesses or video evidence. However, certain factors may help establish liability.

Statements from the parties involved

While self-serving, the accounts of those involved should be considered. Look for inconsistencies in the stories that may indicate a party is not being entirely truthful. The party whose statement aligns most logically with the physical evidence may be deemed more credible.

Physical evidence at the scene

  • Skid marks, debris patterns, and damage to the vehicles can help reconstruct what happened. The location of dents, scratches and other damage may indicate which vehicle struck the other.
  • Photographs and diagrams of the accident scene are invaluable for determining how the collision occurred and which driver was most likely at fault. Accident reconstruction experts can analyze physical evidence to draw conclusions about the sequence of events.
  • Injuries to the parties involved may also point to a particular impact location or provide clues to seat belt usage, which relates to liability. Medical records, photos and testimony from medical professionals should be reviewed.

Witness statements

Disinterested eyewitnesses who provide consistent, logical accounts of the events leading up to and during the accident may help assign fault, especially if their statements are supported by physical evidence. Witness contact information should be obtained as soon as possible before memories fade.

While complex, determining fault in a “he said, she said” accident is possible by thoroughly investigating the available evidence. The totality of the facts, not any single piece of information, should be used to establish liability. With time and patience, the truth can come to light.

Police Reports and Witness Statements

Police reports and witness statements provide crucial evidence in “he said she said” car accidents.###

As an injured party in a disputed liability collision, obtaining the official police report and contacting witnesses should be a top priority. The police report will document the details of the accident, including statements from all drivers and passengers involved, as well as any witnesses. Be sure to request a copy of the full report, including all supplemental details and witness statements.

Witnesses who stopped to provide a statement at the scene may be able to provide additional context about the events leading up to and immediately following the accident. Their testimony could corroborate your account of the incident and help determine fault. Politely contact any witnesses listed in the police report and ask if they would be willing to provide a written statement about what they observed. Offer to have them review and sign the statement.

While police reports and witness statements are not definitive determinations of liability, they form a crucial part of building a case to prove fault in a disputed car accident claim. Comparing all accounts of the incident may reveal inconsistencies that show the other party was at least partially at fault. The details and evidence provided can also help your attorney determine the best path forward to recover damages.

With thorough police reports and additional witness testimony, the events surrounding a “he said she said” car accident can become much clearer. Using these investigative techniques may be key to resolving disputes over liability and securing fair compensation.

Dashcam and Surveillance Footage

Dashcam footage and surveillance cameras can provide crucial evidence in “he said, she said” car accident cases where the details of who is at fault are unclear or disputed.


Dashcams, or dashboard cameras, are cameras mounted inside a vehicle that continuously record video footage of the road and surrounding area. If installed properly, a dashcam can capture video of an accident as it happens, including details like traffic signals, road conditions, and driving behaviors that help determine fault. The footage from your dashcam can serve as key evidence to support your account of the events.

Some tips for using dashcam footage as evidence:

  • Ensure the date and time are properly set in the dashcam. This establishes a timeline of events.
  • Place the dashcam in a location with a wide field of view, like the center of the windshield. Capture as much of the surrounding area as possible.
  • Review and save important footage as soon as possible after an accident. Copy and back up the video in multiple locations in case the original gets damaged or lost.
  • Share copies of relevant footage with the police, insurance companies, and attorneys to aid in determining liability. But do not post footage publicly, as this could influence witness testimony or violate privacy laws.

Surveillance Cameras

Commercial or residential security cameras in the vicinity of an accident may also capture critical footage. Contact nearby businesses, homes, and traffic authorities to request copies of footage from the time of the accident. While less likely, any footage could contain key details about the events leading up to and following the collision.

With conflicting accounts of how an accident occurred, video evidence can provide an objective, factual record of the events to determine who bears responsibility. Dashcams and security cameras are useful tools for substantiating your version of what happened. In a “he said, she said” situation, the footage doesn’t lie.

Working With a Texas Car Accident Lawyer

Working With a Texas Car Accident Lawyer

After an car accident, especially one involving injuries, it is in your best interest to contact an experienced personal injury lawyer in Texas. They can handle communicating with insurance companies and help negotiate a fair settlement for your claim.

A reputable car accident lawyer in Texas will offer a free initial consultation to review the details of your accident and determine if you have grounds for a personal injury claim. They will evaluate factors like the severity of injuries, length of medical treatment, time missed from work, property damage, and who is at fault.

If they believe you have a viable claim, the lawyer will send a demand letter to the at-fault party’s insurance provider. The letter will outline the key details of your accident, injuries sustained, and compensation requested. This starts the negotiation process, which the lawyer will handle on your behalf. They will go back and forth with the insurance company working to maximize your settlement.

Lawyers have a duty to act in the best interests of their clients. An attorney has the knowledge and experience to determine how much your claim is truly worth. They can spot unreasonable offers and will not settle for less than fair compensation. Without representation, insurance companies may take advantage of the situation and offer a settlement that barely covers medical expenses.

Hiring a car accident lawyer in Texas gives you the best chance for a fair outcome. Their expertise and objectivity take the stress out of the claims process so you can focus on recovery. While no one can guarantee a specific settlement amount, reputable lawyers will not charge upfront fees and only collect payment if they win your case.

For the most favorable result from a "he said, she said" car accident claim, seek advice from a personal injury lawyer in Texas. They will evaluate liability, deal with insurance companies, and negotiate the maximum settlement on your behalf. With an attorney, you stand the best chance of gaining rightful compensation after an accident.

Steps to Take After a He Said, She Said Accident

After a "he said, she said" car accident in Texas, it is important to take the proper steps to protect yourself legally and financially.

Call the Police

Immediately call 911 to report the accident to the police. When the police arrive, provide your statement about what happened and get the other driver's information, including their name, address, phone number, license plate number, insurance details, and driver's license number. Request that the police file an official accident report.

Exchange Information

In addition to providing information to the police, exchange information directly with the other driver, even if fault is disputed. Record their statement about the events, as well as contact details for any passengers or witnesses. Take photographs of the vehicles, license plates, insurance documents, driver's licenses, and the accident scene.

Seek Medical Attention

Get checked out by a doctor as soon as possible, even if you feel fine. Adrenaline and shock can mask injuries, and some issues like whiplash may appear later. Obtain records and bills for any medical care to provide to insurance companies.

Contact Insurance Providers

Notify your insurance provider about the accident immediately and file a claim. Provide the details of the incident, information for the other driver, the police report number, and any medical records. Your insurance company will investigate the claim and may contact the other driver's insurance on your behalf. Cooperate fully with your insurance company's requests.

Consult an Attorney

In some cases of disputed liability, it may benefit you to consult with a personal injury attorney. An attorney can advise you on next steps to take, help negotiate with insurance companies, and potentially represent you in court to recover damages if the other driver's insurance denies your claim or does not offer a fair settlement.

Following these steps after a "he said, she said" accident can help establish fault, obtain compensation for any losses, and protect you legally even when liability is unclear. Do not delay in taking action, as failing to do so could jeopardize your ability to recover financially or hold the other driver accountable.

Fletcher Law Texas Injury Lawyers Have Experience To Help

When involved in a “he said, she said” car accident in Texas, it is important to work with a personal injury law firm that has experience in these complex cases. Fletcher Law has successfully litigated hundreds of car accident cases in Texas, helping clients recover damages even when fault is disputed.

Our attorneys understand how to thoroughly investigate an accident, gather evidence from the vehicles and scene, and identify additional witnesses to help determine liability. We work with experts in accident reconstruction, biomechanics and other fields to evaluate how the crash occurred and the forces involved. By piecing together all available information, we build a compelling case to prove which party was at fault.

When multiple parties dispute responsibility, insurance companies will often deny or delay claims hoping the issues will be dropped. The attorneys at Fletcher Law know how to deal with reluctant insurers and will fight to get you the compensation you deserve. We have a track record of negotiating settlements for the maximum amount possible, and are willing to take a case to trial if an adequate offer is not made.

The team at Fletcher Law Texas Injury Lawyers has devoted their careers to helping accident victims and their families. We understand the physical pain, financial stress and emotional trauma that can result from a serious car crash. Our goal is to handle as much of the legal work and paperwork as possible so you can focus on your recovery. If you were injured in a disputed liability accident, call us today for a free consultation and case evaluation. Our experience and dedication can make a difference in obtaining the best possible outcome for your situation.


As you can see, determining fault in a he said she said car accident can be complicated. Witness testimony, physical evidence from the vehicles and scene, and a thorough investigation into the details of how the accident occurred are all critical. While insurance companies may try to dismiss such accidents as no-fault, do not let them off the hook so easily. Work with an experienced personal injury attorney to conduct a full investigation, determine liability, and make sure the at-fault party is held responsible. Your health, financial stability, and right to fair compensation depend on it. Do not settle for less than you deserve. Contact Fletcher Law’s Texas Injury Lawyers for help today.